Skip to main content

Explainer: Can the Paris Agreement’s new carbon market deliver high-quality credits? 

November 17, 2026 Work Area: Land Systems

Early signs suggest Article 6.4 will be considerably more stringent than the Clean Development Mechanism. But the work of establishing the rules that will restore confidence in carbon markets still lies ahead. 

Established under the Paris Agreement, Article 6.4 creates a centralized, UN-supervised multi-lateral mechanism for generating and selling carbon credits. After years of negotiations over its basic rules and governance, the mechanism is now moving into implementation. Earlier this yearf, the UN approved the first credits to be issued under the new system, marking an important milestone. 

Progress has also been made in developing basic standards for crediting methodologies, emissions baselines, additionality, leakage, and reversal risks. However, substantial gaps remain, particularly for forestry and other land-use activities, as well as emerging approaches to carbon dioxide removal (CDR). 

As Article 6.4 moves into implementation, this explainer examines the progress made so far, the outstanding challenges for forestry and land-use activities, what the transition from the Clean Development Mechanism means for existing projects, and what will be needed for the new mechanism to deliver credible climate benefits. 

What progress has Article 6.4 made so far? 

Article 6.4 is the centralized crediting mechanism established under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement. It allows countries and other authorized participants to generate and sell credits from activities that reduce emissions or remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.  

After several years of negotiations, countries have made progress in establishing the mechanism’s operating rules. These include requirements for demonstrating additionality, setting emissions baselines, addressing leakage and accounting for the risk that stored carbon could eventually be released back into the atmosphere. The controversial rules for carbon permanence have been softened and largely punted to individual methodologies.  Five methodologies have been approved, covering activities including landfill gas management, industrial nitrous oxide abatement, renewable electricity generation, and clean cooking. In February 2026, the UNFCCC Supervisory Body approved the first-ever credits under Article 6.4. The credits came from a clean-cooking project in Myanmar that had previously been registered under the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM), the predecessor to Article 6.4 established under the Kyoto Protocol. 

This first issuance offers an early indication of how the new standards will affect future crediting. Applying updated values and more conservative calculations related to the fraction of non-renewable biomass that was reduced by the project, it received approximately 40% fewer credits than it would have under the previous CDM approach – a sign that Article 6.4 is applying stricter requirements to ensure that credits more accurately reflect actual emissions reductions. However, the approval of initial methodologies and the issuance of the first credits do not mean the mechanism is fully operational across all project types. Important methodological gaps remain, particularly for forestry and land-use activities, where measuring carbon stocks and accounting for long-term risks present distinct challenges. 

What makes a high-quality carbon credit? 

At its most basic, a carbon credit represents one metric tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) reduced or removed from the atmosphere. For that credit to have environmental value, however, the claimed reduction or removal must be real, measurable, and independently verifiable. 

Several principles are crucial to determining if a credit represents a genuine climate benefit: 

  • Additionality: Would the emissions reduction or carbon removal happened without the project or the financial incentive provided by carbon crediting? If an activity would have happened anyway, the credits do not represent additional action. 
  • Permanence: How likely is the carbon to remain out of the atmosphere over time? Stored carbon can be released through events such as wildfires, disease, harvesting, or changes in land management. 
  • Credible baselines: How accurately does the project measure emissions reductions against a realistic reference scenario? If a baseline overestimates the emissions that would have occurred without the project, the resulting credits can overstate the climate benefit. 
  • Leakage: Are emissions reductions within a project’s boundaries offset by increased emissions elsewhere? For example, protecting a forest in one location could displace logging or agricultural expansion to another area. 
  • Monitoring and verification: Can the claimed emissions reductions or removals be accurately measured over time and independently verified? Reliable monitoring and transparent reporting are essential to ensuring that credits reflect actual results.Unlike many industrial emissions-reduction projects, which can be measured against relatively well-defined processes, land-based carbon stocks are dynamic. Forests grow, decline, burn, and regenerate. Soil carbon changes with land management, and the effects of a project can take years to manifest and are highly variable.  

These complexities make robust methodologies essential. Without credible approaches to measuring additionality, establishing baselines, accounting for leakage, and managing reversal risks, carbon credits can overstate the climate benefits of a project.  

Why are forestry methodologies particularly challenging? 

Forests present complex accounting challenges. As mentioned above, carbon storage can be reversed through natural disturbances or changes in land management, while project activities can displace deforestation or harvesting elsewhere. 

CATF’s assessment of 20 forest carbon protocols across North America identified weaknesses in additionality, permanence, leakage, monitoring, and verification. With forest-based credits having accounted for nearly 40% of the voluntary carbon market to date, addressing these shortcomings will be crucial to raising the bar for credits across carbon markets. 

Article 6.4 has a clear opportunity to establish stronger, science-based requirements for forestry activities. This will require more dynamic baselines that reflect changing forest conditions, better estimates of leakage beyond project boundaries, and site-specific assessments of reversal risks rather than generalized assumptions. 

Several additional pieces of work are needed to establish a comprehensive framework. These include updating existing CDM methodologies; adopting reversal-risk tools specifically applicable to afforestation and reforestation; strengthening buffer-pool requirements and other remedies when stored carbon is released; and improving monitoring, verification and environmental and social safeguards. 

While the proposed afforestation and reforestation methodology entering the UNFCCC review process in October 2026 is a step in the right direction, a confirmed approval timeline for dedicated forestry methodologies is still outstanding. 

What does the transition from the Clean Development Mechanism mean for forestry projects? 

Article 6.4 allows certain activities registered under the Kyoto Protocol’s CDM to transition into the new mechanism, subject to eligibility, approval, and documentation requirements. The goal is to recognize existing investments while ensuring projects meet the Paris Agreement’s updated standards. 

The transition process involves five stages: project participants submit a request; the activity undergoes stakeholder consultation; the host country provides approval; project participants submit the required compliance documentation; and the UNFCCC conducts checks before approving the transition. The deadline for host-country approval was June 30, 2026. Eligible afforestation and reforestation activities also have a conditional one-year documentation window where an applicable Article 6.4 methodology is not yet available. 

The transition has been challenging. Early-2026 reporting indicated that only approximately 13% of existing CDM credits requesting transition had received host-country approval at that point, illustrating the scale of the work required to fold legacy projects into the new framework and the interest by host countries in retaining credits for domestic use. 

Importantly, transitioning projects does not mean automatically carrying forward the previous system’s crediting assumptions. The first Article 6.4 issuance, which resulted in approximately 40% fewer credits than under the CDM, demonstrates the potential implications of applying more stringent requirements. 

Can Article 6.4 help address the carbon credit crisis? 

Voluntary carbon markets have faced sustained criticism over credits that overstate emissions reductions, lack additionality or fail to deliver lasting climate benefits. These concerns have contributed to greater corporate scrutiny of offsetting claims and purchasing decisions. 

Uncertainty about corporate demand adds another challenge. In April 2026, reports that Microsoft was pausing new carbon removal purchases highlighted the market’s reliance on a relatively small number of major buyers. Article 6.4 could help address some of these weaknesses through a centralized UN framework with common methodologies, oversight, and accounting requirements. Its emphasis on additionality, permanence, transparency, and verification offers an opportunity to establish a more credible foundation for international carbon markets. 

There is a balance to strike between environmental integrity and market participation. Standards must be sufficiently rigorous to protect the quality of credits while remaining practical enough to enable projects to attract investment and scale. Overly burdensome requirements could make participation prohibitively expensive, particularly for nature-based projects and developing countries. However, the lack of stringency in nature-based methodologies of the past led to a lack of confidence that contributed to a slowdown in market scaling. Finally, carbon credits should support additional climate action, not serve as a substitute for reducing emissions within companies’ own operations and value chains. 

Conclusion 

Article 6.4 offers an important opportunity to establish a more credible foundation for international carbon markets, but confidence will not be restored through governance alone. The first credit issuance and approval of initial methodologies are important milestones. The approximately 40% reduction in credits from the first transitioned CDM project offers an early indication that the new mechanism is applying more stringent accounting requirements. 

Forestry will be an important test of whether Article 6.4 can extend that rigor to activities with more complex carbon accounting challenges. CATF’s research on forest carbon and biomass carbon removal protocols underscores the importance of consistent, science-based standards across different project types. 

Ultimately, success should not only be measured by the volume of credits issued, but by whether those credits deliver genuine climate benefits and whether the mechanism mobilizes investment in additional emissions reductions and carbon removal while safeguarding environmental integrity. 

Related Posts

Stay in the know

Sign up today to receive the latest content, news, and developments from CATF experts.

"*" indicates required fields