Skip to main content
Green Forest

Bridging the gap from biomass potential to carbon removal reality

November 19, 2026 Work Area: Land Systems

High-performing biomass carbon removal systems can play a multifaceted role in climate mitigation by removing carbon dioxide directly from the atmosphere, while also potentially capturing emissions that would otherwise be released, reducing reliance on unabated fossil-derived resources, and strengthening land systems and waste management.  

But bridging its gigaton-scale technical potential and growing market commitments into actual delivered removals remains challenging. Today, biomass carbon removal systems deliver removals at the megaton scale (and not all are high-performing), underscoring the need for an ecosystem of solutions to accelerate deployment, improve practices, and scale impact. During New York Climate Week, Clean Air Task Force (CATF) convened a roundtable1 to examine the barriers preventing high-performing biomass carbon removal from reaching its full potential and identify solutions to scaling better practices. Realizing this potential will require both investments and safeguards to ensure systems deliver promised climate benefits while supporting communities and ecosystems.  

High-performing biomass carbon removal systems: 

  • Achieve verifiable carbon removals quantified via rigorous greenhouse gas accounting across the lifecycle of the full system. 
  • Deliver additional community and environmental benefits like economic development, wildfire risk reduction, invasive species management, and improved water quality and soil health while avoiding harm to communities and ecosystems. 
  • Use responsibly sourced biomass especially wastes and residues from improved land management activities. Biomass should ideally be certified, but at a minimum must be tracked and verified, and should not be presumed carbon neutral. 

Overall, the discussion revealed that strong demand for durable removals, including finance and funding, offtakes, and markets, remains a major challenge to scaling the industry. We also explored how barriers manifest across different parts of the biomass carbon removal supply chain. Specifically, we explored the three physical components that make up a system—biomass, bioconversion, and durable carbon storage—and the overarching enabling environment across the value chain. Many of the solutions discussed focused on reducing risk, aligning projects with broader societal benefits, and developing coordinated efforts among supply chain actors, communities, and policymakers both across elements of the physical biomass carbon removal systems and across jurisdictions. Here are some of the key takeaways for each of these three components and the broader enabling policy and finance environment. 

Biomass feedstocks 

Biomass exists in forests, croplands, and waste streams but has many competing uses, including providing ecosystem services. Context-specific policies and safeguards are needed to both support and protect different uses. Accessing, moving, and processing biomass economically and sustainably remain challenging. Traceability, biomass aggregation, feedstock supply chains, and policy development emerged as challenges. Potential solutions included: 

  • Digital infrastructure and trusted entities to improve traceability.  
  • Better technical assistance for biomass suppliers.  
  • Mobile bioconversion units.  
  • Transportation infrastructure to lower costs of segregation and aggregation.  
  • Context- or region-specific biomass hierarchies, guardrails, and policy frameworks tailored to local conditions to avoid perverse outcomes.  

Conversion 

Many technologies covering different stages of commercialization are available for processing biomass for carbon removal (burial, pyrolysis, combustion, gasification, fermentation, and slurry injection were discussed). Different conversion technologies are constrained at different points from technological maturity to markets, infrastructure, permitting, and social acceptance. Still, across conversion technologies, scaling high-performing biomass carbon removal will require policy and innovation to lower project risk and cost. Additionally, stakeholders discussed the importance of linking conversion facilities to broader land management objectives and societal benefits. Modular supply chains and starting by adding carbon removal infrastructure to existing industrial facilities were also discussed as potential solutions.  

Durable carbon storage 

Like conversion technologies, there are many ways to store carbon durably from products and materials to terrestrial chambers to geologic reservoirs. Permitting, social licensing, regulatory coordination, and standardized compliance protocols emerged as barriers to enabling carbon storage. Participants emphasized the need for project developers to work directly with regulators and communities (e.g., matching benefits to regional needs), and, where it makes sense, partner with an existing embedded industry. Participants also identified increased education on durable carbon storage as a priority, particularly to support community and stakeholder understanding. Other barriers, including permitting, measurement, reporting and verification (MRV), and regulatory certainty, will require clearer and more robust frameworks, standards, and technical approaches. 

Enabling environment 

Several critical topics related to the broader enabling environment of finance, policy, and community support were discussed. While not exhaustive, several concrete suggestions emerged. 

Participants discussed the importance of de-risking projects to access institutional and debt financing that is needed to scale. Examples include: 

  • Offtake agreements for both carbon dioxide removal (CDR) and energy co-products. 
  • Long-term contracts to de-risk feedstock supply chains. 
  • Education of risk reviewers for project underwriters, including related to climate risk mitigation value to their broader portfolios. 

From a policy perspective, participants discussed demand-side and permitting improvements such as:  

Demand-side opportunities 

  • Securing a new technology-neutral U.S. federal tax for CDR.  
  • Implementation of Article 6 of the Paris Agreement. 
  • Integration of CDR into the Emissions Trading System and Cross-Border Adjustment Mechanism within the European Union. 
  • Public procurement programs were all cited as policy levers for growing CDR demand. 

Reducing policy barriers 

  • Expand the list of eligible wood uses to include CDR in U.S. Forest Service programs where needed. 
  • Engage state regulators on CDR technologies while addressing the patchwork of state policies that are not yet fit for purpose.  
  • Harmonize policies for permanent carbon storage to address the differences in state primacy over different types of wells. 
  • Establish a consistent permitting process and/or federal backstop for pipelines that cross state boundaries. 

Participants also emphasized the importance of building public trust and partnering with communities from the project initiation stage to build community support. Specific examples include: 

  • Adopting strong independent protocols to support high-integrity credits that also clarify and streamline how to assess leakage.  
  • Sourcing biomass from lands certified by programs managed by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC), Sustainable Forestry Initiative (SFI), and the Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC).  
  • Hiring community liaisons to facilitate community conversations, build relationships with Indigenous Peoples and other experts to gather and incorporate Indigenous and traditional knowledge related to sensitive resources and harvesting practices, and to develop community benefits packages. 
  • Working with local economic development agencies to understand community needs and support job development. 

CATF will continue this work in the months ahead through a survey of industry leaders, an analysis of how different approaches to setting system boundaries in protocols impact the calculation of net carbon removal across different biomass carbon removal systems, and an effort to develop a roadmap (in a case study region) for overcoming barriers to deployment. 


1 50 stakeholders participated under Chatham House rules including CDR developers and industry (16), carbon market experts (11), environmental and policy nongovernmental organizations (9), investors and finance (6), academic researchers (5), climate philanthropy (1), and government/public affairs/policy stakeholders (2). 

Related Posts

Stay in the know

Sign up today to receive the latest content, news, and developments from CATF experts.

"*" indicates required fields