BRUSSELS — The European Commission’s Carbon Removal Certification Framework proposal marks the beginning of a process towards creating a cohesive vision for the deployment of carbon removal technologies, both in Europe and around the world.
“It is critical that regulators develop a strong framework to support the scaling-up of high-quality carbon dioxide removal. The most recent IPCC Report made clear that carbon removals are needed to stave off the worst effects of climate change,” said Kathy Fallon, Director of Land and Climate at Clean Air Task Force. “While the proposed framework is far from perfect, we commend the Commission for stepping up to address a crucial climate policy gap.”
As it stands, the proposal could hamper the contribution of carbon dioxide removals to climate goals by failing to include a well-defined distinction and separation between terrestrial and geological storage, and including comprehensive methodologies for certification and clear separation in the potential uses of these certificates.
While emissions reductions through existing asset and energy system transformation are most pressing, CATF supports the development of all forms of carbon removal where carbon dioxide (CO2) can be verifiably removed from the atmosphere and permanently stored. CATF strongly supports the European Commission’s effort to establish the Carbon Removal Certification Framework (CR CF), which will provide the first ever public initiative to certify carbon removals.
“A removal certification framework is needed in the EU to ensure clear and efficient accounting for CO2 removal and to support the role of carbon dioxide removal in the EU path towards climate neutrality,” said Eadbhard Pernot, Policy Manager, Carbon Capture. “It’s vital that the EU get this right because of their role as a ‘first mover’ regulator.”
This proposal is the latest addition to the European Union’s overall climate ambition and leadership on decarbonization, innovation, and the pursuit of policies to decouple greenhouse gas emissions from economic growth.
The need for a clear definition of Carbon Removal
As CATF has previously outlined, it is critically important that a robust definition for carbon removal be provided. Therefore, the CR CF must only certify removals which are:
- Real – CO2 is removed from the atmosphere and durably stored.
- Measurable – The removed CO2 is quantified via robust monitoring, reporting and verification rules.
- Permanent – Where the durability of CO2 storage is not long-term (beyond 1000 years), legal and financial mechanisms ensure the permanence of CO2 storage in perpetuity.
CATF is concerned that the definition of ‘carbon removal’ in the CR CF Proposal explicitly includes methods which include “the reduction of carbon release from a biogenic carbon pool to the atmosphere.” Under such methods, CO2 is clearly not removed from the atmosphere.
Nevertheless, CATF welcomes the clear distinction between the three types of carbon removal defined by the Commission in the Proposal:
- Permanent Carbon Storage
- Carbon Farming
- Carbon Storage in Products
Protecting environmental sustainability
CATF strongly supports the inclusion of minimum sustainability requirements for the certification of carbon removals. By taking a ‘Do No Harm’ approach, the Certification Framework ensures that removals do not produce negative effects on biodiversity, ecosystems and water resources, among other listed criteria. By excluding practices that are harmful towards biodiversity, such as forest monocultures, and by encouraging practices that have co-benefits for natural restoration targets, the Certification Framework can encourage practices that go beyond the minimum sustainability requirements.
These minimum requirements will ensure that removals are certifiably producing a climate benefit while the availability of certificates on a public electronic register adds needed transparency to the process.
The need to scale up Carbon Removals
CATF welcomes the Commission’s desire to ensure that carbon removal certificates (CRC’s) underpin different end-uses. As the Commission has outlined, carbon removal certificates may provide important sources of public and private investment in carbon removals which will be essential to accelerating the deployment of carbon removal projects.
However, the Proposal for a CR CF lacks considerable clarity on how these CRCs are to be used. In particular, CATF strongly recommends that the three types of carbon removal identified by the Commission be appropriately distinguished in any resulting uses of CRCs generated by the respective types of carbon removal.
Rowan Emslie, Communications Director, Europe, email@example.com,
+32 476 97 36 42
About Clean Air Task Force
Clean Air Task Force (CATF) is a global nonprofit organization working to safeguard against the worst impacts of climate change by catalyzing the rapid development and deployment of low-carbon energy and other climate-protecting technologies. With 25 years of internationally recognized expertise on climate policy and a fierce commitment to exploring all potential solutions, CATF is a pragmatic, non-ideological advocacy group with the bold ideas needed to address climate change. CATF has offices in Boston, Washington D.C., and Brussels, with staff working virtually around the world. Visit catf.us and follow @cleanaircatf.